You’re pulled over on suspicion of DWI. The officer asks you to step out of the vehicle, conducts a series of roadside tests, and eventually places you under arrest. Then comes another question: Will you agree to provide a breath or blood specimen?
A lot of people believe they have two choices: take the test and risk giving police evidence against themselves, or refuse the test and avoid providing that evidence.
Unfortunately, Texas DWI law isn’t that simple.
You can refuse a requested breath or blood test in Texas, but that refusal can carry serious consequences for your driver’s license. And refusing does not necessarily prevent police from obtaining a blood sample.
As a criminal defense attorney practicing in Austin and Central Texas, I think it’s important for drivers to understand what they’re actually agreeing to, what happens when they refuse, and how either decision can affect a DWI case.
Can You Legally Refuse a Breathalyzer in Texas?
Yes, in many circumstances. But there is an important distinction between refusing to voluntarily provide a specimen and preventing officers from obtaining one through lawful procedures.
Under Texas Transportation Code § 724.011, a person arrested for an offense arising from operating a motor vehicle in a public place while intoxicated is generally deemed to have consented to the taking of a breath or blood specimen for analysis.
This is commonly called Texas’s implied consent law.
However, implied consent does not mean police can automatically force every driver to submit to a warrantless blood draw.
Texas Transportation Code § 724.013 generally provides that when a person refuses a requested specimen, the specimen may not be taken except as otherwise authorized by law.
Those exceptions matter.
Officers may seek a search warrant authorizing a blood draw, and certain circumstances are addressed by the mandatory-specimen provisions of § 724.012.
The bottom line is that refusing consent does not necessarily stop the investigation.
What Happens if You Refuse a Breath or Blood Test?
If you refuse a requested specimen after a qualifying DWI arrest, you may face two separate consequences.
1. Your driver’s license may be suspended.
Under Texas Transportation Code § 724.035, a first qualifying refusal generally results in a 180-day driver’s license suspension.
A qualifying prior alcohol- or drug-related enforcement contact can increase that suspension to two years.
This is an administrative penalty, not a criminal conviction.
In other words, your license may be suspended even if the criminal DWI case is later dismissed.
2. The prosecution may use your refusal as evidence.
Texas Transportation Code § 724.061 permits evidence of a refusal to be admitted in a criminal proceeding.
Prosecutors may argue that someone refused testing because they knew they were intoxicated.
That doesn’t mean the argument is necessarily persuasive, or that refusal proves guilt.
There may be legitimate reasons for refusing a test, including confusion about the officer’s instructions, uncertainty about the process, or concerns about the testing procedure.
The circumstances surrounding the refusal should be carefully examined rather than automatically treated as evidence of intoxication.
Can Police Get a Warrant to Draw Your Blood Anyway?
Yes.
This is one of the biggest misconceptions I encounter when discussing DWI arrests.
Some drivers believe that refusing a breath or blood test means the police will have no chemical evidence.
But Texas officers can seek a search warrant for a blood specimen.
If a judge issues a valid warrant supported by probable cause, officers may generally obtain a blood sample pursuant to that warrant, subject to applicable constitutional and statutory requirements.
The United States Supreme Court has addressed the constitutional limits of warrantless blood testing in several important cases.
In Missouri v. McNeely, 569 U.S. 141 (2013), the Court rejected the idea that the natural dissipation of alcohol in the bloodstream automatically creates an emergency permitting a warrantless blood draw.
In Birchfield v. North Dakota, 579 U.S. 438 (2016), the Court distinguished between breath tests and the more intrusive procedure of drawing blood when evaluating searches incident to a lawful DWI arrest.
And in Mitchell v. Wisconsin, 588 U.S. 840 (2019), the Court addressed warrantless blood testing involving unconscious drivers and exigent circumstances.
These decisions are important because they demonstrate that blood testing raises constitutional questions beyond simply whether a person consented.
A warrant does not automatically eliminate every possible defense, either. The validity of the warrant, its execution, and the reliability of the resulting evidence may all warrant examination.
What’s the Difference Between Refusing a Test and Failing One?
Texas treats test refusals and test failures differently for administrative driver’s license purposes.
For an adult driver with no qualifying prior enforcement contacts, the usual ALR suspension periods are:
| Situation | Typical suspension |
|---|---|
| Refusing a requested breath or blood specimen | 180 days |
| Providing a specimen showing an alcohol concentration of 0.08 or higher | 90 days |
These are the usual first-offense administrative suspension periods. Prior enforcement contacts, age, commercial driving privileges, and other circumstances may change the consequences.
But there’s another important distinction.
A test failure and a refusal create different kinds of evidence.
When someone provides a specimen, the prosecution may have a numerical alcohol concentration result.
When someone refuses, the prosecution may instead rely on the refusal, officer observations, driving behavior, field sobriety tests, and other circumstantial evidence.
Neither situation automatically establishes guilt.
Under Texas Penal Code § 49.01(2), intoxication can be established by an alcohol concentration of 0.08 or more or by the loss of normal mental or physical faculties due to alcohol, drugs, or another intoxicating substance.
That means prosecutors can pursue a DWI charge even without a chemical test result.
Do You Have to Perform Field Sobriety Tests in Texas?
Here’s where another distinction becomes important.
The roadside exercises commonly called field sobriety tests are not the same thing as a breath or blood specimen requested under the implied consent statute.
Officers may ask drivers to perform exercises such as:
- The horizontal gaze nystagmus test;
- The walk-and-turn test; and
- The one-leg-stand test.
Generally, a driver is not legally required to voluntarily perform these roadside exercises.
However, refusing them does not necessarily prevent an arrest. An officer may rely on other observations and evidence to determine whether probable cause exists.
Also, roadside preliminary breath testing should not be confused with an evidentiary breath specimen requested after arrest.
Different procedures and legal consequences may apply.
If you are arrested, the most important thing is to distinguish between voluntary roadside investigative requests, statutory specimen requests, and a lawful search warrant.
Can You Fight a DWI if You Refused the Test?
Absolutely.
A refusal does not mean the State has proven its case.
In a refusal case, I would want to examine several issues.
Was the original traffic stop legal?
The Fourth Amendment protects against unreasonable searches and seizures.
If an officer lacked reasonable suspicion to stop the vehicle, evidence obtained following the stop may be subject to suppression, depending on the circumstances.
Did the officer have probable cause to arrest?
An officer’s belief that someone was intoxicated is not the same as legally sufficient probable cause.
The defense should examine the driving behavior, officer observations, roadside testing, statements, and other evidence supporting the arrest.
Were the statutory warnings properly given?
Under Texas Transportation Code § 724.015, officers must provide specified information about the consequences of refusing or failing a requested test.
The timing and content of those warnings may be relevant to administrative proceedings and potentially to the criminal defense, depending on the issue raised.
Was the refusal clear?
The circumstances of the alleged refusal matter.
For example, a driver might misunderstand the request, ask questions, or have difficulty communicating.
Not every disputed interaction should be treated as an unambiguous refusal without reviewing the evidence.
Was a blood-draw warrant legally sufficient?
If officers obtained a warrant after the refusal, the defense should examine the warrant affidavit, probable cause, the scope of the warrant, and the procedures used to obtain the specimen.
Can the State prove intoxication without chemical evidence?
The State still has the burden of proving every element of DWI beyond a reasonable doubt.
An officer’s observations and field sobriety test results can be challenged, and the defense may have evidence that provides a different explanation for the driver’s behavior.
You May Have Only 15 Days to Challenge a License Suspension
One of the most important things to understand after a DWI arrest is that the criminal case and the driver’s license case are separate proceedings.
The administrative proceeding is known as Administrative License Revocation (ALR).
Generally, a driver has 15 days after receiving or being served with the applicable suspension notice to request an ALR hearing.
The deadline may begin when an officer serves the notice following a refusal, or when DPS later provides notice after receiving test results.
You should not assume you have 15 days from the date of arrest in every case.
If you miss the applicable deadline, the suspension can take effect without a contested hearing.
An ALR hearing can also provide an opportunity to challenge the statutory basis for the suspension and examine evidence relevant to the DWI investigation.
For a broader explanation of the criminal process, read our guide to what happens after an arrest in Texas.
So, Is It Better to Refuse a Breathalyzer in Texas?
There isn’t a universal answer.
Refusing a specimen can result in a longer administrative license suspension, and officers may still obtain chemical evidence through a warrant.
Agreeing to a test may provide the prosecution with evidence of alcohol concentration, but that evidence is not automatically conclusive or immune from challenge.
The circumstances of the stop, the arrest, the requested test, and the available evidence all matter.
What I would caution against is believing that either refusing or agreeing to testing automatically determines whether someone will be convicted.
DWI cases are often much more complicated than that.
Frequently Asked Questions
Can I be charged with DWI if I refuse the breathalyzer?
Yes. Texas prosecutors can pursue DWI charges without a breath or blood test result. They may rely on other evidence of intoxication, including officer observations, driving behavior, field sobriety testing, and statements.
Does refusing a breathalyzer automatically mean I lose my license?
Not necessarily. A qualifying refusal may trigger an administrative suspension, but the driver generally has the right to request a timely ALR hearing and challenge the statutory grounds for suspension.
Can the police force me to give blood?
Police may obtain a blood specimen pursuant to a valid search warrant or another legally recognized exception. The circumstances determine whether a nonconsensual blood draw is lawful.
Can I refuse field sobriety tests without losing my license?
Refusing voluntary roadside field sobriety exercises is generally different from refusing a requested breath or blood specimen under Texas’s implied consent law. The refusal of roadside exercises alone does not ordinarily trigger the statutory ALR refusal suspension, although the officer may continue investigating and may make an arrest based on other evidence.
What if the police obtained my blood without a warrant?
A warrantless blood draw may raise constitutional issues, but it is not automatically unlawful in every circumstance. Whether suppression is appropriate depends on the facts, applicable exceptions, and governing law.
Arrested for DWI in Austin or Travis County? Contact ME Law, PLLC.
If you’ve been arrested for DWI, whether you agreed to testing, refused testing, or had your blood drawn pursuant to a warrant, it’s important to have the evidence reviewed before making decisions about your case.
At ME Law, PLLC, we represent individuals facing DWI charges in Austin, Travis County, Williamson County, and surrounding Central Texas communities.
We examine the legality of traffic stops, probable cause for arrest, breath and blood testing procedures, warrant issues, and the evidence prosecutors intend to use. We also help clients navigate the separate administrative driver’s license process.
A DWI arrest is serious, but it is not the same thing as a conviction.
Contact ME Law, PLLC at (512) 503-0707 to discuss your case.
This article provides general legal information and is not a substitute for advice concerning your individual circumstances.